E-Signature vs Digital Signature: What’s the Difference and Why It Matters

The use of electronic signatures (e-signatures) and digital signatures has become increasingly prevalent in various industries. In fact, there has been an increase in global e-signature transactions from 89 million to 754 million in just five years. 

These technologies offer a convenient and secure way to sign documents and authenticate the identity of the person signing. 

However, there is often confusion surrounding the differences between e-signatures and digital signatures. 

In this article, you will learn exactly what e-signatures and digital signatures are, their benefits, how they differ, and how to choose the right one for your needs. Whether you’re signing contracts, legal documents, or managing business transactions, understanding these concepts is essential for anyone navigating the digital age.

What is an Electronic Signature (E-Signature)?

An electronic signature, commonly referred to as an eSignature or e-signature, is a broad category that encompasses various methods of signing documents electronically rather than using paper and ink. 

It can take the form of a scanned image of a handwritten signature, a typed name, a digital representation of a signature, or a unique identifier such as a PIN or password. These are used to indicate the signer’s intent to agree to the contents of a document or transaction.

An eSignature can take various forms, such as: 

• Typed Names: Simply typing your name into a designated field in a document.
• “I Agree” Buttons: Clicking buttons on websites that state you agree with the terms or conditions presented.
• Digital Drawing: Using tools to draw your signature just like you would on paper, but digitally.

E-signatures are recognized legally in many jurisdictions around the world thanks to laws like the U.S. Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act (ESIGN Act) and the European Union’s Electronic Identification and Trust Services regulation (eIDAS). These legislations have paved the way for wider adoption by providing legal standing similar to traditional signatures under certain conditions.

Key Characteristics of an E-Signature

What makes an e-signature legally valid? Several key things must be true: 

• Intent to sign: The person signing must clearly want to sign the document. They are showing their agreement.
• Association with the record: The signature needs to be clearly linked to the document it’s signing. It can’t just float separately.
• Consent to do business electronically: In many places, both sides need to agree to handle their business using electronic documents and signatures.
• Record retention: The signed document should be easy to keep and access for everyone involved. This way, you have a clear record of the agreement.

Common Use Case for E-Signature

• HR documents: Signing new hire paperwork, benefit forms, or employee handbooks.
• Everyday contracts: Approving vendor agreements or service contracts.
• Consent forms: Giving permission for various activities or disclosures.
• Sales agreements: Finalizing deals for products or services.

Potential Security Concerns with eSignatures

While e-signatures offer convenience and efficiency, they may not always carry the same level of security assurance as digital signatures, a more secure subset that uses encryption technologies. 

Some forms of electronic signatures could be easily manipulated or forged if proper verification processes aren’t implemented. 

For instance, typed names or clicked agreements don’t provide evidence about who actually performed these actions without additional authentication measures being taken. Therefore, businesses using this technology, especially for digital contracts, need to ensure that their chosen solution has adequate security features capable of verifying the identity of the user effectively.

Incorporating robust electronic signature solutions like FillFaster can significantly enhance contract management workflows while ensuring compliance with relevant regulations and safeguarding against potential fraud risks associated with less secure methods.

What Is a Digital Signature?

On the other hand, digital signatures are a specific type of electronic signature that offers an added layer of security and authenticity. Digital signatures use cryptographic technology to provide a unique digital fingerprint for both the document and the signer. This ensures the integrity of the document and verifies the identity of the signer.

How Does Digital Signature Work?

Digital signatures operate on the principle of public-key cryptography, establishing a secure and verifiable link between the signer and the document. Here’s how a digital signature works:

• Encryption (Digital Fingerprint): When a document is digitally signed, the system creates a unique “digital fingerprint” of that document. This fingerprint is a complex code called a hash.
• Digital Certificate: A key part of a digital signature is a digital certificate. This certificate is like an electronic ID card. It’s issued by a trusted third party, known as a Certificate Authority (CA) or Trust Service Provider (TSP). The CA checks the signer’s identity and confirms that the digital signature belongs to that person or organization.
• Public and Private Keys: Every digital signature involves two unique, mathematically linked keys:
  • The private key is kept secret by the signer. When you sign a document, your private key is used to create the digital signature.
  • The public key is available to others. It’s used to verify the digital signature and confirm that it came from you and that the document hasn’t been altered.
• Tamper-Evident Seal: If anyone changes the document even slightly after it has been digitally signed, the digital signature will break. This immediately tells you that the document is no longer the original. It’s like a broken seal on an envelope.

Key Security Features of Digital Signature

Digital signatures offer strong security features:

• Authentication: This verifies the signer’s identity. You can be confident in who signed the document.
• Integrity: This guarantees that the document has not been changed since it was signed. You know the content is original.
• Non-repudiation: This makes it very difficult for the signer to deny that they signed the document later on. It provides strong proof of their action.

Benefits of Digital Signatures

These advanced electronic signatures offer a secure and efficient way to sign documents electronically, providing several key advantages over traditional e-signatures.

1. Security

Digital signatures come with enhanced security features that safeguard against fraud and unauthorized access. With this technology, digital signatures ensure the document content remains confidential between the signing parties. This level of security is vital for small to medium-sized business owners who rely on digital contracts for their services.

2. Authenticity

The authentication process behind a digital signature verifies the signer’s identity using their unique personal identification details, such as PIN or biometric data. This ensures that each party involved in the transaction can trust the legitimacy of both the document and its signatories. The rigorous verification process adds an extra layer of assurance for all parties involved.

3. Non-repudiation

A digitally signed document cannot easily be denied by its signer once it has been executed. Non-repudiation prevents any party from disputing their involvement or agreement after the fact, making these types of signatures incredibly reliable in binding agreements.

This feature is particularly beneficial when dealing with high-stake contracts or sensitive information requiring indisputable proof of participation and consent.

4. Integrity

Digital signatures also guarantee that a document has not been altered after signing. Any post-signature modification invalidates it immediately, ensuring complete transparency and integrity throughout its lifecycle. For businesses operating online, this means peace of mind knowing your documents remain untampered from point A to B.

5. Legal Admissibility

In many jurisdictions worldwide, digital signatures hold up in court similarly to handwritten ones due to legislation like the Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act (ESIGN). Their legal admissibility provides an added advantage by streamlining dispute resolution processes should issues arise during contract enforcement phases, offering yet another reason why transitioning to digital signature solutions like FillFaster can be highly advantageous for modern businesses looking toward future-proofing their operations.

Common Use Cases for Digital Signatures

Digital signatures are preferred for situations that require a very high level of security and trust. You’ll often find them used for:

• Highly sensitive legal documents: Such as property deeds, wills, or major contracts, where legal validity and proof of authenticity are paramount.
• Financial transactions: For securing bank transfers, loan agreements, or investment documents.
• Government filings: Submitting taxes, official permits, or regulatory compliance documents where identity verification is critical.
• Medical records: Ensuring the integrity and confidentiality of patient files and prescriptions.
• Regulated industries: In fields like pharmaceuticals or banking, where strict regulations demand the highest level of document security and non-repudiation.

Importance of Electronic Signatures in Modern Business

Digital signing has revolutionized the way business transactions are conducted. It has streamlined processes, reduced paperwork, and accelerated the pace of business. 

Electronic and digital signatures are recognized as legally binding in many countries and are valid means of signing contracts, agreements, and other documents. As businesses continue to embrace digital transformation, the adoption of electronic signatures has become crucial for efficiency and competitiveness.

💡 Electronic signatures are the new normal, making deals faster and greener by ditching paper for clicks. Services like FillFaster can transform contract handling, letting you close deals instantly—even with clients far away. 

Key Differences Between e-Signatures and Digital Signatures

While both e-signatures and digital signatures help you sign documents electronically, they differ significantly in their underlying technology, security, and how they verify identity. Knowing these differences helps you choose the right tool for the job.

Let’s break down the key distinctions:

• Technology: An e-signature can be as simple as typing your name or clicking a button. It relies on basic electronic processes to show intent. A digital signature, however, uses advanced cryptographic technology called Public Key Infrastructure (PKI). This involves complex math and digital certificates to create a secure, verifiable signature.
  
• Security Level: E-signatures offer varying levels of security. Their strength often comes from audit trails, which record when and where a document was signed. Digital signatures, on the other hand, provide a much higher level of security. They are cryptographically secured and designed to be “tamper-evident.” This means any change to the document after it’s signed will invalidate the signature.
  
• Identity Verification: With an e-signature, identity verification might be based on simple methods like an email address, a password, or logging the signer’s IP address. For a digital signature, identity is verified through a digital certificate issued by a trusted Certificate Authority (CA). This CA performs checks to confirm the signer’s identity before issuing the certificate, making the identity verification much stronger.
  
• Evidential Value: In a legal dispute, both types of signatures can be legally binding. However, a digital signature often provides stronger evidence. Its cryptographic security makes it very difficult to argue that the document was altered or that the signer didn’t sign it. E-signatures rely more on detailed audit trails to prove what happened.
  
• Global Recognition and Compliance: Different regions have different rules for electronic signatures. For example, in the United States, the ESIGN Act and UETA (Uniform Electronic Transactions Act) validate most e-signatures. In Europe, the eIDAS Regulation has specific categories, including simple electronic signatures, advanced electronic signatures, and qualified electronic signatures (which are a form of digital signature). Understanding these global standards helps ensure your documents are legally recognized wherever you do business.
  

To help clarify these points, here’s a comparison table:

Feature	Electronic Signature (E-Signature)	Digital Signature
Definition	Broad legal term; any electronic indication of intent.	Specific type of e-signature using cryptography.
Technology	Simple electronic processes (typed name, click, image).	Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) and digital certificates.
Security Level	Varies; generally less secure, relies on audit trails.	High; cryptographically secured and tamper-evident.
Identity Verification	Email, password, IP logging, basic authentication.	Certificate Authority (CA) issued digital certificates.
Document Integrity	Relies on audit trails to show changes.	Cryptographically binds signature to document; invalidates if tampered.
Legal Weight	Legally binding for most everyday transactions.	Often considered the “gold standard” for high-value documents.
Common Use Cases	HR, sales contracts, consent forms.	Financial transactions, government, medical records, legal deeds.

💡 E-signatures are the quick and easy way to sign off on everyday documents, while digital signatures come with heavy security when it matters. 

How to Choose Between an e-Signature and a Digital Signature

When it comes to choosing between e-signatures and digital signatures, it’s essential to assess your specific requirements and consider various factors before making a decision.

Assessing Your Needs: When Simplicity Meets Security

To navigate through this decision-making process effectively, start by assessing your specific needs based on document sensitivity, legal requirements, and geographic location. Here’s how:

• eSignatures for Basic Agreements: For less sensitive documents such as basic service agreements or permission slips, where convenience outweighs security concerns, an eSignature suffices. These signatures capture the intent of the parties involved without embedding any verification data within the document itself.
• Digital Signatures for High-Stakes Documents: In contrast, high-value contracts or sensitive financial statements necessitate using digital signatures. Unlike eSignatures, digital signatures come with added layers of security – they encrypt documents and securely attach the signer’s identity verified through certificate-based IDs issued by trusted entities known as Certificate Authorities (GlobalSign explains Certificate Authorities). This makes them legally binding in many jurisdictions worldwide.

Legal Framework and Compliance

Understanding the laws governing electronic signatures is crucial for any business owner. While many countries have adopted laws recognizing electronic signatures, the specific requirements can vary.

In the United States

The U.S. has two main laws that make electronic signatures legal:

• ESIGN Act (Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act): This is a federal law passed in 2000. It states that an electronic signature, contract, or record cannot be denied legal effect or enforceability simply because it is in electronic form. Its main purpose is to validate e-signatures at a national level for interstate and foreign commerce.
  
• UETA (Uniform Electronic Transactions Act): This act was created to provide a consistent legal framework for electronic transactions across different states. While the ESIGN Act is federal, UETA is a model law that most U.S. states have adopted. It ensures that electronic signatures and records have the same legal standing as their paper counterparts.
  

For an e-signature to be legally valid under these laws, certain requirements generally need to be met:

• Intent to sign: The signer must clearly intend to sign the document.
• Consent to do business electronically: Both parties must agree to conduct business electronically.
• Association with the record: The signature must be clearly linked to the document being signed.
• Record retention: The signed document should be available for all parties to access and keep.

It’s important to note that a few types of documents typically still require traditional “wet” (handwritten) signatures in the U.S. These often include wills, adoption papers, and certain court orders.

In the European Union (eIDAS Regulation)

The European Union has a comprehensive regulation called eIDAS (electronic IDentification, Authentication and trust Services). This regulation provides a framework for electronic identification and trust services across EU member states. eIDAS defines different levels of electronic signatures, each with increasing levels of security and legal weight:

• Simple Electronic Signature (SES): This is the most basic level. It’s similar to a typical e-signature, like a typed name or a scanned signature. It signifies intent but has fewer security requirements.
• Advanced Electronic Signature (AES): An AES offers a higher level of security. It must be uniquely linked to the signer, capable of identifying the signer, created using data the signer can control, and designed to show if the data has been tampered with after signing.
• Qualified Electronic Signature (QES): This is the highest level defined by eIDAS. A QES is created by a qualified electronic signature creation device and is based on a qualified certificate issued by a trusted provider. The QES has the equivalent legal effect of a handwritten signature across all EU member states. A QES is a specific type of digital signature under the eIDAS framework, offering the strongest legal backing.

Global Implications

The choice of signature type has important global implications for your business:

• Security and Trust: The level of security provided by your signature directly affects how much others trust your signed documents. For sensitive information or high-value transactions, stronger security builds greater confidence.
• Legal Enforceability: While both e-signatures and digital signatures are legally binding in most places, digital signatures often provide stronger evidence in legal disputes. This is because their built-in security features make it harder to challenge their authenticity or integrity.
• Risk Management: Choosing the appropriate signature type helps manage risks like fraud, document tampering, or a signer later denying their signature (non-repudiation). Using a digital signature for critical documents can significantly reduce these risks.
• Industry-Specific Requirements: Different industries, such as healthcare, finance, or law, may have specific regulatory requirements or compliance standards. These standards might necessitate the use of digital signatures due to their enhanced security and verifiable identity.
• User Experience vs. Security: There’s often a balance between how easy a signature process is and its security level. Simple e-signatures are very user-friendly, allowing for quick signing. Digital signatures, while more secure, can sometimes involve more steps due to their robust identity verification processes. Your business needs to weigh these factors based on the document’s importance.

Choosing the Right Signature Type

Deciding between an e-signature and a digital signature depends on several factors specific to your business needs. There isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer. By considering the following points, you can make an informed decision that balances security, compliance, and ease of use.

Here are key questions to ask yourself:

1. Consider the nature of the document.

What kind of document are you signing? 

Is it a routine internal memo that just needs quick approval, or is it a high-value financial contract that carries significant risk? 

The importance of the document should guide your choice. For everyday agreements, a basic e-signature might be sufficient. For documents like property deeds or complex legal agreements, the enhanced security of a digital signature is often preferred.

2. Assess the level of risk

What are the potential consequences if the document is altered after signing, or if the signer’s identity is questioned? 

If the financial or legal risks are high, investing in a digital signature solution provides much stronger protection against fraud and disputes. For low-risk documents, simpler e-signatures are usually fine.

3. Understand legal and regulatory requirements

Does your industry or the jurisdiction you operate in mandate a specific type of signature? 

As discussed, some industries (like healthcare or finance) or regions (like the EU for certain documents) have strict rules that might require an Advanced or Qualified Electronic Signature (which is a form of digital signature). Always check if your business needs to comply with particular laws or standards.

4. Evaluate your budget and resources

Digital signature solutions, especially those involving qualified certificates and trusted service providers, can be more complex and costly to implement compared to basic e-signature tools. Consider the initial setup costs, ongoing maintenance, and the resources needed to manage the system.

5. Think about user experience

How critical is ease of use for the people who will be signing your documents? 

Simple e-signatures are generally faster and more straightforward for signers, leading to a smoother process. Digital signatures, with their added security steps like identity verification through a Certificate Authority, can sometimes add more friction to the signing process. Balance the need for security with the need for a good experience for your clients and partners.

Streamlining Business Agreements with E-Signatures

The adoption of eSignatures grew rapidly by 2,300% within five years and is projected to increase further by 69% by 2024. 

More and more businesses are benefiting from the seamless signing experience, thanks to digital signature solution providers like FillFaster. These solutions offer businesses a transformative opportunity to eliminate friction in their agreement processes. 

No more snail mail lagging behind or printers throwing tantrums mid-print job. Now we’re talking real-time deal closures with clients sipping coffee miles away from each other. 

• Faster turnaround times. Eliminate the delays associated with printing, mailing, and waiting for physical signatures. Contracts, proposals, and agreements can be sent, signed, and returned electronically in mere minutes or hours.
• Reduced Errors and Omissions: Automated e-signature platforms often include features like mandatory fields and pre-filled information, helping to minimize errors and the back-and-forth required for corrections.
• Improved Collaboration: Many platforms support real-time collaboration, allowing multiple parties to review, edit, and negotiate a document seamlessly before signing. This can be vital in complex deals or in situations where signatories are located in different areas.
• Enhanced Tracking and Visibility: Gain deeper insights into the status of documents with detailed audit trails and notifications. This transparency helps avoid bottlenecks and ensures that deals stay on track.
• Remote Accessibility: No need to be chained to a physical office. Documents can be securely accessed and signed on any device with an internet connection, facilitating seamless workflow for both your in-office and remote employees.
• Eco-Friendly: Drastically reduce the need for paper documents, conserving resources and minimizing environmental impact.
• Better Customer Experience: Offer clients the convenience of signing electronically from anywhere, improving overall satisfaction and responsiveness.

Streamline Your Signatures with FillFaster

Elevate your document signing process to new heights of efficiency and security. FillFaster offers the ultimate solution for businesses looking to implement e-signatures and digital signatures seamlessly. Whether you’re dealing with high-stake contracts or everyday agreements, FillFaster ensures your documents are signed quickly, securely, and in compliance with legal standards.

Ready to transform how you handle agreements and contracts? 

Contact FillFaster today or reach out via WhatsApp for a streamlined signing experience that propels your business forward.

Frequently Asked Questions